- Big Q: Are all people created equal?
- Big Q: Is art getting better or worse?
- Big Q: Are books dead?
- Big Q: Why are 43 percent of Americans barely able to read?
- Big Q: Who's better at communicating -- men or women?
- Big Q: Are there any modern mummies?
- Big Q: Is texting the end of talking?
- Big Q: Is privacy a dying concept or the next battleground?
- Big Q: Is the Internet making us sicker?
- Big Q: What makes a good citizen?
- Big Q: Is race a social construct?
- Big Q: Can love actually kill you?
- Big Q: Should we force a cap on the U.S. population?
- Big Q: Do prisons create more criminals?
- Big Q: If the 1 percent had less, would the 99 percent really have more?
- Big Q: Are humans meant to be monogamous?
- Big Q: Can humanity counteract the damage it's done to Earth?
- Big Q: Is global warming real?
- Big Q: Is healthy food a right or a privilege?
- Big Q: What is Gender?
- Big Q: Is there a "gay gene"?
- Big Q: Are rich people smarter?
- Big Q: If you saw someone being mugged would you stop to help?
- Big Q: Can music make you smarter?
- Big Q: What role does creativity have in business?
- Big Q: Should your health be public information?
- Big Q: Can prayer heal cancer?
- Big Q: Is there life before birth?
- Big Q: Is racism hereditary? (Is there a racist gene?)
- Big Q: Would the world be different if we all looked alike?
- Big Q: Are we inherently evil?
- Big Q: Is it better to confess a lie or keep it secret?
- Big Q: Will the world end in 2012?
- Big Q: What's the first thing you'd say to an alien?
- Big Q: Is there a sixth sense?
- Big Q: Is God evil?
- Big Q: Should fast food be outlawed?
- Big Q: Why is depression becoming more common?
- Big Q: Will surgeons be replaced by robots?
- Big Q: Can we arrest aging by destroying certain cells in our bodies?
- Big Q: Is any place in the U.S. safe from Mother Nature?
- Big Q: Does the Mayan calendar predict our doom -- will the world end in December 2012?
- Big Q: Did the Mayans use multiple calendars?
- Big Q: Why did the Mayans use a 260-day calendar?
- Big Q: Will humans still look the same 10,000 years from now?
- Big Q: Can the brain solve problems while the body sleeps?
- Big Q: What impact does ocean acidification have on undersea life?
- Big Q: Would we age differently on another planet?
- Big Q: Are near death experiences just hallucinations?
- Big Q: Is fashion empowering?
- Big Q: Can playing games make us smarter?
- Big Q: Could a hacker take down the Internet?
- Big Q: Do animals have a sense of right and wrong?
- Big Q: Do clothes really make the man (or woman)?
- Big Q: Does having children make us happier?
- Big Q: Does monogamy make us happier?
- Big Q: Does quantum foam hold the keys to time travel?
- Big Q: Does the Internet make travel irrelevant?
- Big Q: Does the modern prison system work?
- Big Q: Have credit cards made us poor?
- Big Q: How does science fiction predict the future?
- Big Q: How has the Internet changed politics?
- Big Q: How is globalization changing culture?
- Big Q: Is marriage dead?
- Big Q: Is taxation stealing?
- Big Q: Is the "American Dream" really possible?
- Big Q: Is the U.S. Constitution out of date?
- Big Q: Is there an ideal form of government?
- Big Q: Is your personal information the new currency?
- Big Q: What are the odds of surviving a plane crash?
- Big Q: What does 'free speech' really mean?
- Big Q: What does it take to explore the Mariana Trench?
- Big Q: What is fashion?
- Big Q: What is the future of the book?
- Big Q: What is the future of travel?
- Big Q: Why are humans competitive?
- Big Q: Why does fashion change?
- Big Q: Why does health care in the United States cost so much?
- Big Q: How much longer will we use paper currency?
- Big Q: Is technology killing our ability to practice patience?
- Big Q: Who is the world's most powerful person?
- Big Q: Does good grammar still matter?
- Big Q: Is Internet access a right or a privilege?
- Big Q: Are we getting dumber?
Big Question: Is there an ideal form of government?
The representative form of government practiced by the U.S. isn't the only way to run a country, but is it, or some other method, the ideal approach?
Curiosity contributor Bambi Turner looks at the benefits, and effectiveness, of representative democracy.
Every form of government, from liberal democracy to aristocracy to state communism, comes with its own unique issues. For example, democracy offers a measure of fairness and equality, but also can be inefficient. The opposite is true for monarchies and other models where power is concentrated at the top but where the efficiency of a single leader sacrifices a great deal of fairness and equality. In order to compare various systems of government, one must first determine what the goals of government should be, and what the people are willing to sacrifice to achieve them.
Leaders like John Adams and John Locke argued that the ideal form of government provides the greatest happiness or utility to the largest number of people. Each proposed using a representative assembly or legislature that must be paired with a separate executive and/or judicial branch to ensure checks and balances. This form of government not only allows each citizen to vote based on individual concerns, but also ensures that no one person or group will gather enough power to threaten the representative democracy. A representative democracy, in which the people elect executives and legislators to vote on their behalf, also offers a more responsive and efficient governing body than a direct democracy, which would require cumbersome popular votes to decide every issue.
Further support for this form of government comes from the World Bank, which ranks nations according to a "Government Effectiveness" score, based on how well each government meets the needs of the people. The countries that rank highest on this scale -- including the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Australia and several Scandinavian nations -- all maintain some form of bicameral, multi-party, representative government. By contrast, governments that were part of the former Soviet Union; those located in Sub-Saharan Africa; and nations in Southern Asia -- many of which are not truly representative, multi-party democracies -- rate fairly poorly. Countries scoring lowest are likely to have a one-party system, a military or monarchy, or a state of government so disordered it is best described as anarchy [source: Andrews].
Most Watched
First Video of a Giant...
16,109 views
Looking for the Giant ...
7,923 views
Discovering the Giant ...
7,124 views
N. Myhrvold: Science &...
6,198 views
Major Environmental Is...
4,862 views

































Comments ( )